Jodi Mullins, Cosmetic Medicine Book with Jodi

Home Compare treatments

Compare

Options for acne scarring.

Acne scars come in different shapes and depths, and most respond to a combination of treatments over time rather than one procedure. This guide compares the options on this site.

The question

Acne scarring happens when inflammation damages the collagen beneath the skin and it heals unevenly. Most acne scars are depressed, sitting below the surrounding skin. They are often described in three broad shapes:

  • Rolling scars: broad, soft-edged dips that give the skin a wavy look;
  • Boxcar scars: wider depressions with sharper edges;
  • Ice-pick scars: narrow, deep, pitted scars.

Many people have a mix. Raised scars, and the flat red or brown marks left after a breakout settles, are different again and are approached differently. Because scar types and depths vary across the same face, a combination of treatments over time is usually needed. Not every scar can be corrected; the realistic aim is improvement.

Side by side

OptionMay be considered forTypical downtimeTypical course
Skin needlingMild rolling scars, overall textureAbout 1–3 daysOften 3–6 sessions, 4–6 weeks apart
Morpheus8Rolling and some boxcar scars, deeper textureAbout 2–4 days; marks up to about a weekOften around 3 sessions, 4–6 weeks apart
Erbium laserShallow boxcar scars, surface textureAbout 3–7 daysOne or more
CO₂ laserMore pronounced scarring with texture changeAbout 5–10 days; pinkness for weeksOften one, sometimes repeated
IPLLingering red marks after acne (not the scar itself)Redness for hours to a dayOften several sessions
Healite IISupporting recovery between treatmentsUsually none expectedAround other treatments
Skin health planningCalming skin, brown marks, protecting resultsNone expectedOngoing

Ice-pick scars and some deep or tethered scars may respond only partly to these treatments, and some may be better assessed by a doctor for procedures outside this site.

How each option works

Skin needling

Fine needles create controlled micro-injury, prompting new collagen to form beneath shallow scars. Change is gradual and builds over a series. See skin needling.

Morpheus8

Radiofrequency heat delivered through needles reaches deeper than standard needling, remodelling collagen at the level where many scars sit. See Morpheus8 and skin needling vs Morpheus8.

Erbium and CO₂ laser

Fractional ablative lasers remove microscopic columns of skin, softening scar edges and renewing the surface while collagen remodels beneath. See Erbium, CO₂ and CO₂ vs Erbium.

Supporting care

IPL may help lingering redness after acne. Healite II LED may be used to support healing. Skin health planning keeps skin calm, helps with brown marks and protects results. Regenerative treatments may form part of a longer plan.

Who each may suit

  • Mild, shallow scarring: skin needling is often a starting point.
  • Moderate rolling or boxcar scarring: Morpheus8 or laser resurfacing may be considered, often in combination.
  • Scarring with sun damage and rough texture: Erbium or CO₂ resurfacing may be considered if you can take the downtime.
  • Darker skin types or a history of pigment change: lower-heat options and careful settings are often discussed, because of the higher risk of post-inflammatory pigmentation.

Active acne should be under control before scar treatment, as new breakouts can create new scars and treatment over active acne can spread inflammation. If acne is ongoing, assessment by your GP or a dermatologist is the right first step.

Treatment may also be deferred during pregnancy, with skin infection or cold sores, with a history of keloid scarring, or with some medications.

Recovery and risk differences

Recovery generally increases from skin needling, to Morpheus8, to Erbium, to CO₂. Deeper and more heat-based treatments usually mean more redness, swelling, peeling and time before you feel comfortable socially.

Across all of these, infection, pigment change, prolonged redness and, uncommonly, new scarring are possible. Burns are a consideration with Morpheus8 and lasers. Skin prone to acne may also break out after treatment. See skin needling aftercare, Morpheus8 aftercare and risks and complications.

How Jodi decides

Jodi maps your scars by type, depth and area, and considers your skin type, pigment history, whether acne is still active, your medical history, medications and how much downtime suits you. A plan is often staged over months, with different treatments for different scar types.

Improvement is usually gradual and partial, results vary, and some scars change little. Jodi will be clear about what is realistic for your skin.

The most appropriate treatment depends on the cause of the concern, your skin, medical history, tolerance for downtime and desired outcome.