Jodi Mullins, Cosmetic Medicine Book with Jodi

Home Compare treatments

Compare

CO₂ vs Erbium.

Two resurfacing lasers that share a principle but behave differently in the skin. This guide explains the differences, and why the choice between them is made at consultation.

The question

CO₂ and Erbium are both ablative resurfacing lasers. They remove tiny areas of skin on purpose, and the skin’s healing response renews the surface and remodels collagen beneath it. Both are usually used in a fractional pattern, which treats thousands of microscopic columns and leaves untreated skin in between to speed healing.

The useful question isn’t which laser is stronger. It’s which pattern of skin injury, heat and recovery suits your concern, your skin type and the time you can set aside to heal. For some people the answer is neither.

Side by side

CO₂Erbium
Wavelength10,600 nm2,940 nm
What absorbs itWater in the skinWater in the skin, much more strongly than CO₂
Main effectRemoves tissue and leaves a wider zone of heated tissue around each columnRemoves tissue more precisely, with less surrounding heat
Pinpoint bleedingLess likely, because heat seals small vesselsMore likely at deeper settings
Typical social downtime (fractional)About 5–10 days, depending on depthAbout 3–7 days, depending on depth
Pinkness after healingOften several weeks, sometimes 2–3 monthsOften 1–4 weeks
Typical courseOften one treatment, sometimes repeatedOne or more, depending on depth and concern
Pigment change riskPresent; higher in darker skin types and with sun exposurePresent; may be lower in some selected patients, but never absent

These are typical ranges only. Depth, density, the area treated and your own healing all change the picture.

How each option works

CO₂ laser

The CO₂ laser heats the water in skin cells until a microscopic column of tissue vaporises. Around each column, a rim of tissue is heated without being removed. That heat contributes to collagen remodelling, and it is part of why CO₂ is often chosen for more pronounced texture, etched lines and sun damage.

The same heat is also why recovery tends to be longer, pinkness lingers, and the risk of heat-related pigment change needs careful thought. Read more on the CO₂ laser resurfacing page.

Erbium laser

Erbium light is absorbed by water so strongly that most of its energy is used up right where it lands. It removes tissue cleanly, in very fine and controllable layers, with a thinner zone of heat around each column. On some devices extra heat can be added to change how it behaves. Which Erbium modes are offered: Jodi to confirm.

Less heat generally means a shorter recovery at comparable depths, but it can also mean a more modest change per treatment. Read more on the Erbium laser resurfacing page.

Who each may suit

CO₂ may be considered if

  • texture, fine lines, sun damage or selected scarring are more pronounced;
  • you can set aside a week or more for visible healing, and accept pinkness for weeks afterwards;
  • your skin type carries a lower risk of pigment change, and you can avoid the sun closely during recovery.

Erbium may be considered if

  • concerns are milder or more superficial, such as fine texture or early sun damage;
  • a shorter recovery matters, even if that means more than one treatment;
  • a more precise, lower-heat approach is preferred for your skin. Evidence comparing pigment risk between the two lasers is limited, so this is judged case by case.

Either may be deferred or unsuitable if

  • you have an active skin infection, an active cold sore, or a recent tan or fake tan;
  • you are pregnant or breastfeeding, have a history of keloid or poor wound healing, or take certain medications;
  • the main concern is deeper sagging, which may be better assessed for surgery;
  • a spot or mole is new, changing or unusual. That needs assessment by a GP or dermatologist first.

Recovery and risk differences

Both lasers cause expected effects: redness, swelling, warmth, weeping, a bronzed or crusted surface and then peeling. With CO₂ these tend to be stronger and to last longer. Pinkness after the new skin forms is common with both, and usually longer with CO₂.

Expected with both

  • Redness and swelling, most noticeable in the first few days
  • Weeping, bronzing or light crusting, then peeling
  • Tightness and sensitivity while the skin heals
  • Pinkness for weeks after healing

Less common complications with both

  • Infection, including cold sore reactivation
  • Darkening of the skin (post-inflammatory pigmentation), or less commonly lightening, which can appear months later
  • Prolonged redness, more often after deeper CO₂ treatment
  • Breakouts or milia (small white bumps)
  • Scarring, which is uncommon

Strict sun protection matters for weeks after either laser, which is a real consideration on the Sunshine Coast. Many people plan resurfacing for the cooler months. See the CO₂ aftercare, Erbium aftercare and risks and complications guides.

How Jodi decides

Jodi holds a Queensland laser use licence and performs regenerative ablative laser procedures. Before recommending either laser, she looks at:

  • what is causing the concern and how deep it sits in the skin;
  • your skin type and how your skin has responded to sun, heat and injury before;
  • your medical history, medications and previous treatments;
  • how much downtime you can realistically take, and when;
  • whether one deeper treatment or a series of lighter ones fits your goals better.

Sometimes the answer isn’t a resurfacing laser at all. Morpheus8, skin needling or IPL may suit a particular concern better, and good skin health planning supports whichever option is chosen.

The most appropriate treatment depends on the cause of the concern, your skin, medical history, tolerance for downtime and desired outcome.